On One Elsewords: It’s Long Past Time to End the Tyranny of High-Stakes Testing in Public Education
Hey friends,
Today we’re highlighting Nora De La Cour’s latest for Jacobin magazine where she writes about the devastating and imminently avoidable impact of high stakes testing:
When I taught at an alternative public school for kids with exceptional social-emotional, behavioral, and learning needs, one of my students — I’ll call him Dante — got As in every class he took. School staff would frequently elevate Dante’s extraordinary focus and commitment as an example for his peers.
In the spring of Dante’s senior year, his counselor informed him he’d earned the status of valedictorian. His beaming smile of pride after hearing the news affirmed everything I love about public education. When his mother found out, she burst into tears of joy.
Then, abruptly, we were informed that there had been a mistake. Because Dante’s exceptional learning needs made it impossible for him to pass the Massachusetts Comprehensive Assessment System (MCAS) — the standardized tests that Massachusetts requires high school students to pass prior to graduation — he would not receive a diploma. Without a diploma, he couldn’t be valedictorian — even though, according to his grades and the unanimous judgment of his teachers, he clearly deserved the honor. A wave of incredulity rippled through the staff as we tried to resign ourselves to this obviously cruel, unfair reality. For Dante, the news was devastating.
Even before the “giant federal wrecking ball” (to borrow leading education policy analyst Diane Ravitch’s phrasing) known as education reform, evidence from diverse fields had demonstrated a scientific concept known as Campbell’s Law: the more we base social decision-making on a specific quantitative measure, the more likely it is that that measure will become distorted, ultimately corrupting the processes it’s intended to monitor.
Check out the rest of Nora’s piece at Jacobin here.
Solidarity Forever.
This is so incredibly infuriating and sad.
I used to volunteer with my then-wife at a gifted homeschooling/unschooling outfit called "Beyond IQ", which partially addressed these kinds of issues—Profoundly Gifted children who did poorly in public schools and with standardized testing.